ESRC Digital Good Network

Long read

Indigenous peoples and digital good living: When technology needs to learn to listen, Alex Potiguara.

Originally published in Portuguese on The Conversation.


Artificial intelligence is helping us imagine the future.

But whose future is it, and who is it for?

When we ask AI tools, such as generative artificial intelligence models, to show us “Indigenous peoples in the future”, the results tend to look similar: painted bodies, untouched forests, and a sense of time frozen in place. It is a stereotyped imaginary, far removed from the reality of communities that use mobile phones, produce content, and participate in political debates online.

This tension gave rise to research I carried out in 2025 with members of 11 Indigenous peoples from Latin America. The objective was simple, yet profound: to understand what Digital Good Living means for Indigenous peoples in Latin America.

It all began with an experiment. In 2023, through the AI/AI: Artificial Intelligence, Art and Indigeneity project, coordinated by Professor Thea Pitman (University of Leeds), Andreas Rauh (Dublin City University – DCU), and Sebastian Gerlic of the Thydêwá NGO, a group of Indigenous participants were invited to create images of what their communities might look like in 50 years, as a way of exploring the racial biases these tools tend to reproduce. Instead of futuristic scenarios disconnected from nature, the images that emerged integrated technology, spirituality, territory, and collective relationships. Wich can be explored in detail in the publication Artificial Intelligence, Art and Indigeneity.

But an uncomfortable question soon emerged: where do the data used by these tools come from? Who authorised the use of these images? And, more importantly, can a machine-generated image represent knowledge that was never shared?

These questions connect with wider debates about digital colonialism and large-scale data extraction.

These questions led to the INDIGENIA: Generative AI for Indigenous Futures and ‘Digital Good Living’ project in 2024, led by the same researchers involved in AI/AI, but this time with support from the Digital Good Network (DGN). I contributed to INDIGENIA as a participant. Over five days, leaders, artists, and Elders met in person at the headquarters of Assindi in Maringá, Brazil. The initial proposal was to create new images using artificial intelligence. However, the group decided not to feed systems whose data origins were not transparent, and the discussion shifted towards ethics, consent, and data sovereignty – a central issue in debates on Indigenous Data Sovereignty.

It was in this context that a manifesto was created, setting out principles to guide companies and governments in the development of technologies that affect Indigenous peoples. But manifestos alone do not transform realities. Troubled by this, I began to ask myself: how can we give power to a manifesto?

In 2025, I had the opportunity to coordinate a further stage of the research through a fellowship at the University of Sheffield, with support from the DGN. I was able to extend the study together with Indigenous partners from 11 peoples across Latin America through the project Indigenous Peoples and Digital Good Living. Participating peoples included the Palta (Ecuador), Wichí (Argentina), Aymara (Bolivia), Mapuche (Chile), Potiguara, Kaingang, Tupi Guarani, Kariri-Xocó, and Guarani Kaiowá (Brazil). In this new stage, the aim was to turn the principles of the manifesto into action. To do so, we used the participatory Dragon Dreaming method across six online “digital campfires” and an in-person gathering at Tabaçu Reko Ypy Village in Peruíbe, São Paulo, Brazil. Sixteen people participated in total.

The central concept in these discussions was to imagine “Good Living”, and the research was guided by the following question: how can the principles of the manifesto created in 2024 be translated into concrete actions for building Indigenous Digital Good Living? The question may seem simple, but for these peoples, whose ways of thinking differ profoundly from the dominant worldview, it emerges as a unique opportunity to bring to light alternatives for “postponing the end of the world”. Digital Good Living is not individual. It is collective. And it extends beyond humans.

It is not possible to be well if the community is not well. There can be no balance if the land is sick. Rivers, animals, plants, and ancestors are all part of the same system of life.

Some peoples have specific words to express this idea, such as Sumak Kawsay (Palta), Suma Qamaña (Aymara), or Chiquin’la Loloba (Tulián). Others do not have a single term. This generated an important debate: does academia insist on translating concepts that do not need to be translated?

Forcing a definition can itself be a form of imposition.

From these conversations, we updated the manifesto created in 2024 and developed an action plan containing 28 initiatives. Five were selected as priorities: creating digital networks between villages, recording the knowledge of Elders, training multipliers, producing accessible content, and strengthening digital education in communities.

The IndiGenAI network also emerged – where “AI” refers not only to artificial intelligence, but also to Ancestral Intelligence. It is an open network without a formal structure, connecting Indigenous people and allies interested in building fairer pathways for the use of technology.

The findings raise a central question: are we experiencing a digital transformation – or simply a new form of extractivism?

Where exploitation once focused on physical territories, today it extends to data, images, and traditional knowledge – a phenomenon frequently described as digital extractivism.

In this context, the research points towards a possible path. Listening to communities is not enough. We need to build together, with transparency and respect for decisions about what may – or may not – be made public.

This choice also shaped the research itself. The “digital campfires” were not made public in full, in accordance with the ethical agreements established with participants. The public materials produced afterwards are therefore translations of that process – not its raw data.

Some of these outputs are publicly available, including meetings and recordings on YouTube and open workshops, such as this one on Indigenous data protocols and sovereignty.

Another important effect was internal: some participants reported that they had never reflected deeply on the impacts of digital technologies on their communities. We then came to understand the manifesto not only as an external guideline, but also as an invitation to self-reflection.

Technology, after all, is not neutral. It carries values, interests, and disputes.

For the peoples involved in the research, Digital Good Living requires the same principles as life in the physical world: collectivity, respect for the land, and balance among all beings.

Perhaps the most important question is not what technology can do for us, but what we need to change in ourselves so that it does not reproduce the inequalities we already know.

Publication note

This is an English translation of the article originally published in Portuguese by The Conversation Brasil. The original article and its Portuguese republications can be accessed through the links below:

Alex Cosmo De Mesquita

Alex Portiguara

Alex Potiguara holds a PhD in Intelligence Technologies and Digital Design from PUC-SP. He is a researcher working on artificial intelligence, digital ethics, and sociotechnical governance, with a focus on the implications of digital technologies for Indigenous peoples. His research examines the critical use of generative AI, data sovereignty, and the construction of fairer digital futures.